I have finally attempted the Momofuko Compost Cookie recipe. I have not been to the Momofuko Milk Bar yet (though the Noodle Bar is amazing and highly recommended), but I saw their compost cookies being prepared on Regis & Kelly almost two years ago. Upon hearing how you can really put whatever you want in them -- chips, candy, and really any savory or sweet snack -- I knew that I would have to make these one day. I have to admit that when I have thought about really making these cookies in the past, I have actually become a little overwhelmed with the options -- I mean really, if you could make a cookie with ANYTHING, what would you put in it? Should you play it safe, with the pretzels, potato chips, chocolate chips, etc., or go all out with Doritos, Cheetos, and other completely unnatural food products?
Well, finally, I pulled myself together to make the cookies -- they are just cookies, right, and not something to get completely stressed about? Unfortunately, when I actually decided to bake them, my indecision led to day-off trips to the grocery store and lots of thinking in the kitchen about whether my mixture of ingredients was just right. Additionally, I found a few different ways to find the Compost Cookies online -- one version from the Regis & Kelly show, with a few website critiques of how to best prepare them, as well as a version from the Oprah website, which had significantly different ingredients. Ultimately, I pulled together something based on these two blogs' versions of the Regis & Kelly-featured cookies.

Per the websites' guidance, I put in slightly more flour than called for in the recipe - perhaps 1/4 cup. I also included slightly more of the savory and sweet snacks - 1 1/4 cups of crushed potato chips (Lay's reduced sodium), 1/3 cup of blue corn tortilla chips (Xochitl), 1/2 cup of dark chocolate chunks, 1/2 cup m&ms, 1 cup crushed kit kats. I also included 1 tsp. of kosher salt instead of 2 tsps. because I was worried about the salt from the potato chips and tortilla chips. I also used a handheld mixer instead of a stand mixer, and creamed the butter and sugars together for less time than called for in the original recipe.
I baked the cookies in two different batches - one had been been in the fridge for just over an hour, and then in the freezer for 20 minutes, before baking at 375 in the oven for 15 minutes. I rotated the cookie sheet twice on the same rack during the baking. The second batch was in the fridge for a day or two, and then in the freezer, but I did not notice a different in the outcomes between the two batches.
The cookies were pretty good, though perhaps a little thin. I think when I make these cookies again, I'll put in the full 2 tsps. of kosher salt, and also include thicker chunks of snacks that will withstand the baking, e.g., pretzels, pretzel m&ms, or even hard candy chunks? The chips and chocolate pieces just softened too much while baking, so the cookies just seemed to lack both proper thickness in size and an optimal amount of crunch while eating them. To the next round!
